Mandela: Leadership Control Versus Economic Control Part 4

edit this professional portraittcmp Nelson Mandela

Part 4 Of 5: Mandela, The Divided Alliance And The Changing Centre Of Power 

As disagreements over economic transformation deepened within the liberation alliance, how much influence did Mandela retain over government policy, and was Thabo Mbeki increasingly taking charge? 

By 1996, tensions within South Africa’s governing liberation alliance were becoming increasingly difficult to contain. The disagreements centred on the direction of economic policy, the way decisions were being made and the influence of organisations that had helped bring the African National Congress (ANC) to power. 

For Nelson Mandela, managing these tensions became an important part of governing. At the same time, Deputy President Thabo Mbeki was assuming greater responsibility for the daily coordination of government.

 

The Alliance Under Pressure 

The closure of the Reconstruction and Development Programme (RDP) office in March 1996 caused considerable concern among the ANC’s alliance partners, particularly the Congress of South African Trade Unions (COSATU). The decision was taken without adequate consultation, raising fears that the government’s economic priorities were changing. 

Those concerns intensified on 14 June 1996, when Finance Minister Trevor Manuel announced the Growth, Employment and Redistribution strategy, known as GEAR. 

GEAR emphasised fiscal discipline, trade liberalisation, private investment and tighter control of public spending. The government argued that these measures would encourage investment, stimulate economic growth and create employment. COSATU and the South African Communist Party (SACP), however, criticised the limited consultation surrounding its introduction and argued that the strategy represented a departure from the alliance’s expectations of economic transformation. 

The dispute exposed a serious problem. Organisations that had fought alongside the ANC were questioning whether they still had meaningful influence over the economic decisions of the government they had helped elect. 

More significantly, the disagreement pointed to a wider shift in the balance of power. Political authority rested with the ANC, but economic policymaking was becoming increasingly concentrated within government, while alliance partners found their influence over major decisions more limited than they had anticipated. 

Mandela was directly involved in the dispute. He objected to public criticism from alliance partners, particularly its tone, and demanded an apology from the SACP leadership. However, he also recognised the importance of preserving the alliance. At the SACP Congress in 1998, he reaffirmed that relationship and acknowledged the ANC’s willingness to listen, negotiate and make concessions, including over GEAR. 

Who Was Running The Government? 

Alongside these policy disagreements, Mbeki was assuming greater responsibility for coordinating government. 

This was a gradual process, not an abrupt transfer of presidential authority. Mandela had envisaged a role in which he would set the broad direction of government, supervise its work and intervene when necessary. Over time, however, stronger coordination structures developed within the Deputy President’s office. 

In 1997, a Coordination and Implementation Unit was established there. Mbeki also initiated Cabinet cluster committees to improve coordination across government departments. He increasingly chaired Cabinet meetings, although Mandela generally attended and continued to contribute. 

Mandela remained actively involved in national stability, reconciliation and international relations. Mbeki, meanwhile, became increasingly central to policy coordination and the daily administration of government. 

This arrangement raises a larger question about the location of power itself. If Mbeki was increasingly coordinating government and driving policy implementation, where did ultimate authority over economic decisions reside? When major decisions such as GEAR were taken, how should responsibility be understood between the President who led the government and the Deputy President who increasingly managed its daily operations? 

Mandela’s Own Words 

The clearest insight into this changing balance of authority came from Mandela himself. 

In a televised interview on 14 December 1997, he openly described the relationship between his office and that of his deputy. He said: “I am a de jure President and Thabo Mbeki is already a de facto President.” He added: “I am pushing everything to him and I’m a ceremonial president.” 

These were remarkable words from a sitting head of state. They openly acknowledged the difference between holding presidential office and exercising much of the practical responsibility for running government. 

In the same interview, Mandela spoke about the personal demands of leadership. He said he missed having time to think, read and spend time with his children and grandchildren. 

His remarks reveal the pressures of the presidency and his intention to prepare his successor. They do not establish that he had lost the capacity or willingness to govern. Rather, they show that he was deliberately reducing his direct involvement in the daily administration of government. 

Who Carried The Responsibility? 

Mandela’s growing delegation did not remove his responsibility for decisions taken during his presidency. 

GEAR was adopted by Mandela’s government. Although Mbeki’s influence over policy coordination was increasing, the strategy cannot fairly be attributed to him alone, nor can Trevor Manuel be treated as its sole author. It was a government policy developed and adopted through a collective political process. 

Important questions remain. What alternatives were considered? How seriously were the objections of COSATU and the SACP weighed? Could the government have pursued a different balance between investment, fiscal discipline and redistribution? 

In December 1997, Mbeki was elected ANC president, succeeding Mandela as leader of the party. He became South Africa’s national president in June 1999, following Mandela’s completion of his single term. 

Mandela’s presidency ended with a significant transfer of practical responsibility, but he remained accountable for the direction taken by his government. The economic consequences of those decisions form an important part of his presidential legacy. 

In Part 5, we examine the unfinished business of liberation, the economic legacy of Mandela’s presidency and whether political freedom delivered the economic transformation millions of South Africans had expected. 

image 3tcmp

Ola Aina is a Black British journalist based in London, specialising in African affairs. She reports on politics, social change, and culture across the continent, bringing depth and context to underreported stories. Through insightful, human-centred journalism, her work connects UK audiences with Africa’s complexities, challenges, and opportunities 

Author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

error: Content is protected !!